Abstract: Interoperability refers to the effective exchange of information and understanding to collectively pursue common objectives. System developers commonly use ontologies to enhance semantic and syntactic interoperability within this context. This work aims to evaluate the contribution of ontology in making explicit the meaning of the entities described in a Piping and Instrumentation Diagram (P&ID) model and to provide an architecture that allows the representation of a P&ID in ontological knowledge bases. To understand the semantics of the P&ID entities and relations, we map each class of the P&ID to the corresponding entity of the Offshore Petroleum Production Plant Ontology (O3PO). The ontology describes the definition of each vocable associated with the axioms that clarify and regulate the meaning and utilization of this vocabulary. We intend to guarantee that the integration of P&ID with other models respects the original semantics and avoids unintended data exchanges. We follow this ontological analysis with a case study of a model that conforms to the Data Exchange in the Process Industry (DEXPI) specification, intended to provide homogeneous data interchange between CAD systems from diverse vendors. The ontological analysis of the DEXPI P&ID specification, to build a relation with a well-founded ontology, raises a set of desirable properties for a model intended for use in interoperability. While achieving technical interoperability between DEXPI P&IDs and ontologies represented in OWL is evident, we identified several challenges within the realm of semantic interoperability, specifically concerning clarity/intelligibility, conciseness, extendibility, consistency, and essence. These issues present significant hurdles to achieving seamless systems integration. Moreover, if the DEXPI standard were to evolve into a de facto standard for representing P&IDs across a broader range of domains than initially intended, these highlighted issues could potentially bottleneck its adoption and hinder its integration into different systems.

Keywords: Ontology, Interoperability, Data EXchange in the Process Industry (DEXPI), Piping and Instrumentation Diagram (P&ID), Industrial standard and Oil & Gas.

Author: Rafael Humann Petry
Advisor: Mara Abel
Co-advisor: Nicolau Oyhenard dos Santos

Dissertation: Bachelor final work

Publication: http://hdl.handle.net/10183/266808